A History of the CMLA

In the last quarter of the 19th century, America’s medical community recognized an increasing need for medical libraries where medical books and journals were assembled for the use of all. Usually, such collections were established as part of a local library, but medical societies in a few cities, such as Boston, New York and Philadelphia, had free standing medical libraries. From 1870, the physicians of Cleveland had placed medical literature in the Case Library, a private library just east of Cleveland’s downtown public square.

On the evening of November 27, 1894, a group of physicians representing the Cleveland Medical Society, the Cuyahoga County Medical Society, and the Society of the Medical Sciences gathered for the purpose of establishing a formal medical library… Before the evening ended, the Cleveland Medical Library Association was born. Several of the founding members made significant gifts of money to assure that the new library would be a stable and on-going enterprise.

In its first years, the Library Association continued to occupy a small space in the Case Library, but in1898, the Association purchased the Henry Childs residence on Prospect St., a short distance from the center of the city. With continuing strong support in the form of money for operation and for endowment, especially a major endowment from Dudley Peter Allen, a principal founder of the library who died in 1915, the Association was in an excellent position. With this stability, additional property adjoining the Childs’ residence was purchased in 1919 with the thought of erecting a new building for the Library. By 1922, the Association engaged the noted Cleveland architectural firm of Walker and Weeks to prepare plans.

When the plans were shown to Mrs. Elisabeth Severance Prentiss, widow of Dr. Allen, she offered significant funding for the new building under the conditions that its location was farther from town and it was named for Dudley Peter Allen. At this time Western Reserve University’s medical school (now the medical School of Case Western Reserve University) was about to move from its downtown location to University Circle where it would be adjacent to the University. Lakeside Hospital, associated with the medical school, was about to make the same move. Eager to have a medical library close to these institutions, the University invited the Library Association to build its new building near the medical school. On November 13, 1926, the Allen Memorial Medical Library was opened at the corner of Euclid Avenue and Adelbert Road., a short walk from the school and the hospital.

The building was designed by Frank R. Walker and Harry E. Weeks, noted for their excellent work throughout the mid-West and particularly in Ohio. In Cleveland, they left the largest legacy of important buildings of any architectural firm in the city’s history, including the Federal Reserve Bank, the Cleveland Public Library, Severance Hall, and the Allen Library. Although they worked in many styles, they were leading exponents of the classical revival in the 1920s and the Allen has been called “ Walker and Weeks at their best.” This neoclassical building was inspired both by French and Italian Renaissance models and by the monuments of antiquity. In 1983, the Allen was entered in the National Register of Historic Places.

Rapid collection growth had characterized the Library since its founding. In spite of the Depression years, the Association never lost site of the fact that the collections were what it was all about and sufficient money was always available for purchases. Within ten years of opening, the Allen boasted of a collection of 50,000 volumes, with 430 periodicals arriving every month from all over the world. The Library was on its way to becoming one of the leading medical libraries in the country.

In addition to being the home of the Library Association, the Allen was, for many years, the home of The Academy of Medicine of Cleveland. The Academy occupied the west side of the first floor, and shared the first floor auditorium and dining facilities in the basement with the Association.

The Allen Library became the temporary home for the rare books of the Army Medical Library (now the National Library of Medicine) in 1942. The move from the Washington area was prompted by the war and a fear that these treasures might become the victim of the same destruction occurring in Europe. Seventy-five tons of materials arrived, and the Cleveland Branch of the Army Medical Library took over most of the third floor of the Allen Library, where it remained until the early 1960s.

The Library Association also had a rare book collection that was rapidly expanding. The first book that the Association owned (a gift in 1893) was a rare mid-16 th century anatomical study by Andreas Vesalius. Gifts and purchases, including a special 50 th anniversary drive in 1944 to augment the rare book collection, resulted in a sizeable rare book collection within the Library. Continued attention to the collection in following years has led to a collection today that is among the finest in the country. At the same time the rare book collection was emerging, a collection of historical medical artifacts was also taking shape. Dudley Allen was a proponent of this collection, and when Dr. Howard Dittrick was put in charge of the emerging museum in 1915, the collection grew rapidly. He amassed a collection that would be impossible to duplicate today. The Dittrick Medical History Museum, named for Dr. Dittrick in 1944, is a leader in the field . The establishment of an Archives of Medical History, emphasizing Cleveland and Northern Ohio, occurred in the 1960s. These three historical collections are known today as the Dittrick Medical History Center.

The 1950s and 1960s brought more change and growth to the Library. A professional staff replaced trustee committees that previously operated the Library with very limited assistance. The close proximity of the Allen Library and the University’s medical school, assured a close relationship. In 1948, the medical school established a central medical library which they had not had before, and in the late 1950s, the Association and Case Western Reserve University began discussing mutual concerns regarding library needs and development. By 1960, the talks focused on how the libraries could formally work together operationally and administratively to the advantage of both. As a result, the two institutions entered into an agreement to operate their respective medical libraries as if they were one. Shared staff, shared purchases, and operational integration created a more efficient and cost effective library that was well prepared to enter the fast approaching electronic age. Together, the two libraries were named The Cleveland Health Sciences Library. The integration of the two libraries was further enhanced in the late 1990s when the Association and the University renewed the agreement binding them. Additionally, the Dittrick Medical History Center became part of the College of Arts and Sciences in 1997, and thus has been further integrated into the life of the University.


J.E. Cook: 1894-1895

H.E. Handerson: 1896-1902

D.P. Allen: 1903-1906

H.G. Sherman: 1907-1910

G.B. Parker: 1911-1913

B.L. Millikin: 1914-1915

J.P. Sawyer: 1916-1920

W.E. Bruner: 1921-1922

C.A. Hamann: 1923-1924

H.L. Sanford: 1925-1926

F.E. Bunts: 1927

S.W. Kelley: 1928

W.T. Corlett: 1929-1930

G.E. Follansbee: 1931-1932

R.H. Birge: 1933-1934

W.H. Weir: 1935-1936

A.A. Jenkins: 1937

C.H. Lenhart: 1938-1939

C.L. Gummer: 1940-1941

F.S. Gibson: 1942-1943

Howard Dittrick: 1944-1945

L.A. Pomeroy: 1946-1947

Harold Feil: 1948-1949

H.N. Cole: 1950-1951

R.M. Stecher: 1952-1954

H.B. Wright: 1955

R.D. Leas: 1956

C.W. Wyokoff: 1957

C.S. Hibley: 1958

W.P. Garver: 1959

D.K. Spitler: 1960

W.P. Chamberlain: 1961

C.L. Hudson: 1962

D.A. Chambers: 1963

P.F. Partington: 1964

F.A. Simeons: 1965

A.B. Schneider: 1966

Harry Hauser: 1967

Ruth Rauschkolb: 1968

D.M. Glover: 1969

T. Hale Ham: 1970

Walter H. Pritchard: 1971

Kent L. Brown: 1972

Robert E. Holmberg: 1973

Elden C. Weckesser, M.D.: 1974

Scott R. Inkley, M.D.: 1975

Harvey J. Mendelsohn, M.D.: 1976

Stanley O. Hoerr, M.D.: 1977, 1980

Charles Q. McClelland, M.D.:1978

John H. Sanders, M.D.: 1979

Robert A. Hagn M.D.: 1981

Joseph M. Foley, M.D.: 1982

Hiram H. Hardesty, M.D.: 1983

Saul M. Genuth, M.D.: 1984

Robert J. White, M.D., PhD: 1985

Francis F. Silver, M.D.: 1986

Harvery J. Dworken, M.D.: 1987

Edward H. Bloch, M.D., PhD: 1988

Oscar D. Ratnoff, M.D.: 1989

Ralph C. Wieland, M.D.: 1990

John R. Judge, M.D., J.D.: 1991

William E. Bruner II, M.D.: 1992

Richard B. Fratianne, M.D.: 1993

Donald W. Junglas, M.D.: 1994

Robert Bruce Cameron, M.D.: 1995

Theodore J. Castele, M.D.: 1996-1997

Lansing C. Hoksins, M.D.: 1998

Edward L. Westbrook, M.D.: 1999

Robert W. Shields Jr., M.D.: 2000

Michael W. Devereaux, M.D.: 2001

Melvin Shafron, M.D.: 2002

Anthony S. Tavill, M.D.: 2003

Dale H. Cowan, M.D., J.D., F.A.C.P: 2004

Lawrence T. Kent, M.D.: 2005

Irvine G. McQuarrie, M.D., PhD: 2006

Irving Kushner, M.D.: 2007-2008

Stephen A. Rudolph, M.D., PhD: 2009-2011

Edwin H. Eigner, M.D.: 2011-2013

Stuart C. Morrison, M.D.: 2013-2015

Elisabeth Severance Prentiss (1865-1944)

Elisabeth Severance Prentiss was an esteemed art collector and philanthropist who, along with her family, left a monumental impact on the CMLA and the entire Cleveland community. She was born on 1865 to parents Fanny Benedict and Louis Severance, and spent her early years in Cleveland, Ohio before attending school at Wellesley College in Wellesley, Massachusetts. In 1892, she married Dr. Dudley Peter Allen, an accomplished and innovative surgeon who was a primary founder of the Allen Memorial Medical Library through his gracious endowment. Throughout their lives together, they accumulated a remarkable art collection, and contributed tremendously to supporting and advancing the medical community in Cleveland. After Dr. Allen’s passing in 1915, Elisabeth continued to give back to the medical community, and she worked to develop and grow St. Luke’s Hospital, where she met, and later married its president, Dr. Francis Fleury Prentiss. They both became trustees of the hospital, and after Dr. Prentiss’s death, Elisabeth stepped in and became its president. Elisabeth made several notable philanthropic efforts throughout her life, including funding the constriction of the Allen Memorial Hospital and the Allen Art Museum in Oberlin, Ohio, founding the Elisabeth Severance Prentiss Foundation, and leading the funding of the Allen Memorial Medical Library, ensuring that it was named in honor of her late husband. In 1928, she was awarded with the Cleveland Medal for Public Service, and was the first woman to have accomplished this. The CMLA continues to honor Elisabeth’s selfless commitment to improving the medical community around her, and recognizes her as a principal benefactor of the organization.


Dudley Peter Allen (1852-1915)

Dudley Peter Allen was a renowned surgeon and professor who was the principal founder of the Cleveland Medical Library Association. He was born in Kinsman, Ohio to a family with a rich history in medicine, and attended Oberlin College before going to Harvard Medical School to become an M.D. in 1879. He eventually settled in Cleveland, Ohio, where he served as a predominant voice in the medical community as a surgical professor at Western Reserve Medical College, as well as the chief surgeon at Lakeside Hospital. He published many articles on surgical history and ethics during his time at Western Reserve, and was an eminent collector of art works, specifically Chinese porcelain. In 1894, Allen founded the CMLA, and served as its president between 1903 and 1906. To support the organization, Allen donated his entire personal medical library to the CMLA, where it now still exists at the Allen Memorial Medical Library, named in honor of him.


John H. Lowman (1849 – 1919)

John H. Lowman, M.D., was an esteemed doctor, professor, and philanthropist who dedicated his life to pursuing a cure and spreading awareness for tuberculosis. He is nearly solely responsible for Cleveland’s current reputation as a leader in tuberculosis treatment and prevention, as he founded the Anti-Tuberculosis League of Cleveland and Cuyahoga County, as well as the Ohio Public Health Association. He served as a professor at the Western Reserve Medical College, where he became Professor of Materia Medica and Therapeutics, and Professor of Medicine. Dr. Lowman was an impassioned speaker and lecturer who, among his many positions and responsibilities in the medical community, found time to inspire those around him and do everything in his power to fight against tuberculosis. Upon retirement, he provided a generous endowment to the CMLA, where he is now honored in the Allen Memorial Medical Library through the John H. Lowman Room.


Hunter Holmes Powell (1843-1915) 

Hunter Holmes Powell (1843-1915) was a prominent obstetrician, medical educator, and early Trustee of the Cleveland Medical Library Association. Powell came to Cleveland from Virginia in 1872 and joined the faculty of Western Reserve’s medical school. He became Lecturer and then Professor of Obstetrics and the Diseases of Children, and was considered Cleveland’s premier obstetrician. As Director in Charge of St. Ann’s Maternity Hospital, Powell offered his students valuable first-hand experience in obstetrics, something not common at the time. He served in many capacities at the medical school, including Dean from 1895 to 1900. Powell was also deeply involved in establishing guidelines and regulations for the profession, and campaigned for a medical library in Cleveland, helping to lay the groundwork for the Cleveland Medical Library Association. Powell generously gave his time to medical charities, being the presiding genius of St. Ann’s Maternity Hospital for 30 years. He served as Trustee from 1898 to 1906.


Henry Ebenezer Handerson (1837-1918)

Henry Ebenezer Handerson, M.D., (1837-1918) was a medical historian, writer, and professor who was a founder and president of the CMLA. He was born in Cleveland, Ohio where he spent much of his early years before attending boarding school and Hobart College in New York. For most of his childhood, Handerson struggled with frequent illness, but maintained his resolve in pursuing medicine after his time as a volunteer for the Stafford Guards in the American Civil War. He studied medicine at the College of Physicians and Surgeons in New York, where he became an M.D. in 1867. Handerson then practiced medicine in New York City until 1885, when he returned to Cleveland. During his time in Cleveland, he pursued his passion for medical history and writing, publishing several meticulous papers on the medical history, sanitation, and diseases of the city. In 1888, he met and married Clara Corlett, who he raised two children with. Towards the end of his career, Handerson served as the professor of hygiene and sanitary science at the University of Wooster from 1894 to 1896, and at the Cleveland College of Physicians and Surgeons from 1896 to 1907. During this time, he also served as president of the CMLA from 1896-1902 after helping found the organization, and continued to play an essential role in its operations for the rest of his life.


Harvey Williams Cushing (1869-1939)

Harvey Williams Cushing, M.D., was a major pioneer of neurosurgery whose work has left a monumental impact on neuroscience and the entire medical field. He was born on April 8, 1869 in Cleveland, Ohio into a large family with a history of esteemed physicians, and spent his childhood there before attending Yale University, where he graduated with a B.A. in 1891. Following his graduation, Cushing studied medicine at Harvard University and received his M.D. in 1895. He spent most of his career practicing in Baltimore, where he made countless contributions to medicine, including discovering the Cushing reflex and Cushing’s disease, developing several techniques for surgical operation on the brain, and training and mentoring many other neurosurgeons, like Walter Dandy, who eventually made their own lasting impact on the field. In addition to his medical achievements, Cushing served as a colonel in World War I, where his surgical expertise saved numerous lives and earned him a Distinguished Service Medal from the U.S. Army. He also became a Pulitzer Prize winning author in 1926 for his work in writing a powerful biography of Sir William Osler. By the end of his illustrious career, Cushing had amassed several awards and honors, including the Lister Medal, the Cameron Prize for Therapeutics of the University of Edinburgh, and serving as a fellow of the American Philosophical Society, Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, and the Royal Society of London. Upon his retirement from medical practice, he became the Sterling Professor of Neurology at the Yale School of Medicine. Today, his portrait (pictured below) is displayed at the Allen Memorial Medical Library in the Cushing Room.


Henry Justus Herrick

Dr. Henry Justus Herrick was born on January 20, 1833 in Aurora, Portage County, Ohio. He graduated from Williams College in 1858 and Rush Medical College in Chicago, Illinois, in 1861. After medical school he came to the Cleveland area to work at the U.S. Marine Hospital under Dr. Martin L. Brooks. Dr. Herrick was commissioned assistant surgeon and then promoted to surgeon with the 17th Ohio Volunteer Infantry during the Civil War. He was captured at the battle of Chickamauga and spent two months as a prisoner of war at Libby Prison. After the war ended, he became a professor and became chair of gynecology and hygiene in the medical department of Western Reserve University. He was a member of several medical societies and wrote articles for various medical journals. He died in 1901.


B. L. Millikin (1851-1916)

Benjamin Love Millikin (1851-1916) was a leading ophthalmologist in Cleveland, Dean of the Medical Department of Western Reserve University, and founding member of the Cleveland Medical Library Association. He was born in Trumbull County, Ohio, and received his medical degree from the University of Pennsylvania in 1879. Millikin supplemented his education by interning at the Wills Eye Hospital in Philadelphia, and visiting Europe’s premier ophthalmologic clinics. In 1882 he opened a private practice in Cleveland, and was attending physician at several hospitals and dispensaries in the city. In 1893 he became Professor of Ophthalmology at Western Reserve. While Dean there, from 1900 to 1912, Millikin saw the school through a period of notable progress, during which it entered the first rank of institutions of modern scientific medicine. In addition, he was Dudley Peter Allen’s closest associate in the planning and establishment of the Cleveland Medical Library Association. Millikin served as a Trustee from 1898 until his death, Vice-president between 1911-1913 and as President in 1914 -1915. He died in 1916 just as he had been re-elected for President, leaving behind a bequest to the Library of 25,000$ which was used to aid the purchase of the 122 feet frontage on Prospect Avenue for the Library.